“Acting is fake; money is real!”
This reviewer must begin by saying that he is absolutely, positively not the target audience for I Play Rocky. This reviewer grew up in a world awash with Sylvester Stallone films from his meteoric rise in the late seventies, his heyday in the early eighties, to his current position as a sunsetting action hero emeritus. This viewer has seen everything from Rocky to First Blood, Over the Top, Tango and Cash, Stop or My Mom Will Shoot, Cliffhanger, Demolition Man and Judge Dredd through to the more mature Copland and his recent Expendables series. It’s fair to say this reviewer has watched Rocky itself at least half a dozen times.

To those who have never seen1976’s Rocky or are unfamiliar with Stallone’s work, I Play Rocky can come off as a somewhat intriguing, scruffy-underdog-proves-‘em-wrong character study. This reviewer largely found the film to be an ungainly, rough-hewn parody. The film solidified unconfirmed rumors this reviewer had heard that swirled around the shoot. However, this reviewer only found one thing interesting that he was completely unaware of while watching I Play Rocky. The film immediately cut away from the subject and never returned to it. Really, just go see Rocky.
“How come every time I say “No”, you raise the price?”
“It’s called negotiations.”
I Play Rocky is a 2026 Amazon/MGM distribution directed by Peter Farrelly from a story by Peter Gamble. Anthony Ippolito leads an ensemble cast including Matt Dillon, Tracy Letts, AnnaSophia Robb, Toby Kebbell, Stephan James, P.J. Byrne and Jay Duplass.
“Sylvester. I like it; it’s got a nice ring to it. Sylvester Stallone, like Peter Parker.”
It is Hollywood, 1975. Unpolished actor Sly Stallone (Ippolito) has come west with his new wife, Sasha (Robb), to follow his dream of becoming a movie star. Sasha convinces him to audition as Sylvester instead of calling himself Mike. His auditions are unsuccessful, but Stallone is given an opportunity to meet with producers Bob Chertoff (Kebbell) and Irwin Winkler (Byrne). The executives are impressed with his raw talent and writing skills. They encourage Stallone to send them more scripts.
None of his ideas click with the producers, but he doggedly continues his creative process. He still hasn’t landed a part, and one day, Sasha tells him she’s pregnant. Sylvester takes his dog, Bupkus, for a walk while he heads down to buy groceries for the couple.
Stallone realizes he doesn’t have enough money for dog food, After the dumb motherfucker sells his dog- buys cigarettes and can buy beer but sells his fucking dog- he goes to a bar to drown his sorrows. The bartender has the fights on the TV, and they watch Muhammad Ali go 15 rounds with some schnook named Chuck Wepner who just will not quit. By the end of the bout, Stallone realizes that the raucous patrons aren’t rooting for the champ; they’re cheering for Wepner, the nobody, the underdog.
Inspired, he returns home and grinds out the screenplay for Rocky in three and a half days. Chertoff and Winkler are astounded. They want it. They make some calls and contact Sandy Maddox (Letts), a foul-mouthed executive at the United Artists production company, who greenlights the project. They’re authorized to buy the project and the script from Stallone. There’s only one catch. Stallone is determined to play the lead and adamant that he won’t sell the script at any price without a deal containing a contractual caveat promising him that performance.
His father Frank (Dillon) presses him to take the money. Buy a house, get some stocks, and take care of his pregnant wife. Sylvester sees the opportunity as his Golden Ticket and he can’t let it go. He has to star in the movie he’s written. The producers keep cranking up their offer, but Stallone is tenacious and unyielding. Sylvester suspects he’ll never have this kind of leverage again.
Will Stallone listen to his father and take the money? Will the inexperienced creator be taken for a ride by the Hollywood system? Will the crew fall behind schedule, allowing the studio to regain control of the shoot and cut Stallone out? If you’d like to find out, please see I Play Rocky.
“My advice? Just do the best acting in your life.”
Michael Fuchs plays engineer Garrett Brown, who invented the Steadicam, a stabilizing armature and counterweight connecting a camera to an operator’s harness that allows them to walk a camera over any terrain and get smooth tracking shots. Brown first used his prototype in 1974, filming his wife at local landmarks. The graceful footage of her running up the steps towards the Philadelphia Museum of Art inspired director John Avildsen to use the device when it came time to film Rocky as his impossibly tight shooting schedule (and lack of permits) precluded the construction of dolly rails. Rocky would be the third film to use the device following 1976’s Bound for Glory and Marathon Man. The device would be crucial for capturing the many training montages in the movie as well as the boxing matches themselves.
Avildsen would be rewarded for his early adoption of cutting-edge technology; Rocky was nominated for ten Academy Awards, winning three. The movie about the down-on-his-luck palooka making good won Best Picture, Best Director, and Best Editing at the Oscars that year.
Stallone appeared in 1974’s The Lords of Flatbush and 1975’s shlocky Roger Corman classic, Death Race 2000, before he was able to get Rocky to the screen.
This reviewer knows it would have been tricky to keep Ippolito from moving the lower left side of his face, but something practical could’ve been done if CG wasn’t on the menu. Perhaps a prosthetic. It’s very off-putting to watch the lower left side of his face move constantly, but it’s especially egregious right after he tells his new girlfriend that he can’t move the lower left side of his face. This is noticeable to the point that it kept reminding this reviewer that Ippolito’s impression varies in quality tremendously over the runtime. I Play Rocky frequently falls into the inauspicious and awkward chasm that too-long SNL skits often do. Some of the New York accents sound as forced and fake as Kevin Costner’s British accent in 1991’s Robin Hood: Prince of Thieves. Many jokes fell flat to the unresponsive audience. Lots of characters smoke, but it’s simply not enough. There’s not remotely enough smoke in the air to be a reasonable recreation of 1976.
There are some critical emotional beats that are shortchanged. Though I Play Rocky tries to work in several of the classic montages from Rocky, they’re stripped of emotional impact as they are part of the movie within the movie. Those sections of the film are repeatedly given short shrift. Even critical moments are given summaries, with I Play Rocky using snippets and quick cuts to tell crucial parts of its story. In this reviewer’s opinion, wait for streaming and really, just go see Rocky.
I Play Rocky is currently in limited release and will open nationwide on 11/20/2026.

